Bernie Madoff was born in 1938 in a lower-middle-class neighborhood in the New York borough of Queens. Chin presided over the criminal trial of Oscar Wyatt, the Texas oil executive accused of making kick-backs to the Saddam Hussein regime during the UN Oil-For-Food Program. Extraordinarily evil By the time Judge Chin entered his chambers on the morning of Monday, June 29, he had decided what his draft was missing, he said. I don't think so," he said. As Fordham University School of Law's inaugural Lawrence W. Pierce Distinguished Jurist in Residence, Judge Denny Chin of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit says he . The request was denied. He stole from the poor. As agents scoured records for evidence of a broader conspiracy and cultivated DiPascali as a cooperator, the scandal turned Madoff into a pariah, evaporated life fortunes, wiped out charities and apparently pushed some investors to die by suicide. } A graduate of Princeton, Chin couldn't get a paying job after his first year at the Fordham University School of Law, so he interned for a judge in New York's Southern District, then clerked for the same judge following graduation. School teachers, farmers, mechanics and many others also lost money. "How could somebody do this to us? As Michael Patrick noted when he introduced Judge Chin at the luncheon at which he received New York County Lawyers Association's Edward Weinfeld Award: "Denny presided over both high profile and low pro-file cases. How do you excuse deceiving your family, your investors and an industry you spent your life trying to improve? 2023 by the Rector and Visitors of the University of Virginia. Madoff's case has become symbolic of Wall Street greed and a laissez-faire attitude toward federal oversight. ", "I'm terminally ill," he said. It all came crashing down in the winter of 2008 with a dramatic confession at Madoff's 12th-floor apartment on the Upper East Side. Chin assumed senior status on June 1, 2021. Thanks (I guess) Judge Chin, 57, said he learned he had received the Madoff case from his staff as he entered his chambers on March 6, 2009, after a court proceeding. He also responded to the assertion in Mr. Sorkins letter that the unified tone of the victims statements suggested a desire for a type of mob vengeance that would seemingly negate the judges role. Mr. GEORGE NIERENBERG: I called him Madoff. There was also Carla Hirshhorn, who said she was thankful that her father died before he realized that his wife's financial security was ruined. #inline-recirc-item--id-942a1cd6-8c88-11e2-b06b-024c619f5c3d, #right-rail-recirc-item--id-942a1cd6-8c88-11e2-b06b-024c619f5c3d { Early life. "I saw what a great job [being a federal judge] was," he said. Although he went through an extensive background check, "my confirmation hearing took about five minutes, maybe three minutes it was that simple.". "Charles Ponzi is now a footnote," said Anthony Sabino, a defense lawyer specializing in white collar criminal defense. "[6] While a student at Princeton, Chin was a staff writer and later managing editor at The Daily Princetonian. In the 1980s Bernard L Madoff Investment Securities occupied three floors of a midtown Manhattan high-rise. They were two struggling kids from Queens. In the middle of his trial, Wyatt changed his plea to guilty as part of a plea bargain with the government. He concluded it was not reasonable to permit the government to search the homes and seize the computers of thousands of individuals merely because their e-mail addresses were entered into a web site, where, in addition to gaining access to child pornography, they could engage in text-based activities such as participating in chat rooms and answering surveys. Madoff was sent to do what amounted to a life sentence at Butner Federal Correctional Complex, about 45 miles northwest of Raleigh, N.C. . Judge Denny Chin. And he turned, he looked at me, but he never looked at the victims. For reasons of symbolism, and to further the principles of retribution and deterrence and to keep faith with victims, Bernard Madoff was sentenced to a 150 years in prison. U.S. Court of Appeals Judge Denny Chin, of New York City, is a naturalized citizen. In bankruptcy filings, trustee Irving Picard said family members "used customers' accounts as though they were their own," putting Madoff's maid, boat captain and house sitter in Florida on the company payroll and paying nearly $1 million in fees at high-end golf clubs in Florida and on Long Island, N.Y. Picard has sought to reclaim ill-gotten gains by freezing Madoff's business bank accounts and selling off legitimate portions of his firm, Bernard L. Madoff Investment Securities LLC. Judge Chin read his passage on retribution, which, after the length of the sentence itself, appeared to have the greatest impact. He insisted that he acted alone, describing a separate wholesale stock-trading firm run by his sons and brother as legitimate. Menaka Guruswamy, Arundhati Katju Helped Win Landmark Ruling in India, Consumer Information (ABA Required Disclosures), Asian Pacific American Law Students Association (APALSA), Jamar Walker 11 Makes History as First LGBT Federal Judge in Virginia, Sean Onwualu 24 Trades in Playbooks for Casebooks, LGBT Rights Litigators To Receive Jefferson Medals in Law, Big Data and War: Can a Cyberattack Warrant an Armed Response? Roadways to the Bench: Who Me? "When Peter or Bernie said something that they were going to do, their word was their bond," Morling said in a 2008 interview. As a federal judge in the Southern District of New York, Judge Denny Chin sees some of the most cutting-edge cases in the country, so much so that three of his cases were used as plots for the popular Law and Ordertelevision series. Frank DiPascali, the companys chief financial officer, said in a guilty plea in 2009 that the statements detailing trades were all fake. Bernie Madoff leaves federal court in 2009. The courts probation department had recommended a 50-year term, while the government had requested 150 years. The United States Senate Committee on the Judiciary reported Chin's nomination to the full Senate on December 10, 2009[10] and he was confirmed by a 980 vote on April 22, 2010. Read about our approach to external linking. Judge Chin and his wife Kathy Hirata Chin have written, produced, and presented, together with a team from the Asian American Bar Association of New York, a series of reenactments of historic cases involving Asian American litigants. From his grandfather, a waiter, and his father, a cook in Hell's Kitchen,. Copyright 2023 CBS Interactive Inc. All rights reserved. Denny Chin (; born April 13, 1954[1]) is a Senior United States circuit judge of the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, based in New York City. There, with his brother and later two sons, he ran a legitimate business as middlemen between the buyers and sellers of stock. Mr. Madoff, speaking by phone from federal prison in Butner, N.C., said he believed that Judge Chin went along with the mob psychology of the time., Explain to me who else has received a sentence like that, Mr. Madoff said. I do not agree, Judge Chin wrote about the victims. The benefits of giving him hope were far outweighed by all of the other considerations.. Pence won't commit to supporting Trump if he's the nominee Video, At the crash site of 'no hope' - BBC reporter in Greece, Harry and Meghan told to 'vacate' Frogmore Cottage, China and Belarus call for peace in Ukraine, Rare Jurassic-era bug found at Arkansas Walmart, Ed Sheeran says wife developed tumour in pregnancy, Dozens of girls treated after new Iran poisonings, Man survives 31 days in jungle by eating worms. "We're in a complicated situation. After spending several months under house arrest at his $7m penthouse apartment, he was led off to jail in handcuffs, to scattered applause from angry investors in the courtroom. Amanda Leith, a lawyer for NBC Universal, had no comment on the ruling. Three weeks after Chin ruled on a commercial breach of contract case involving plaintiff's lawyer Larry Klayman, Klayman wrote a letter to Chin asking if he had any connection to John Huang or the Democratic National Committee. ", First published on April 14, 2021 / 9:47 AM. Bernard Madoff, right, leaves US . The bureau said Madoff's cause of death would be determined by a medical examiner. [24], In 2016, Chin joined the panel that upheld Tom Brady's suspension by Commissioner Roger Goodell for the Deflatgate scandal, In 2009 Chin presided over U.S. v. Madoff. }, First published on February 26, 2008 / 5:54 PM. Soon after, Tom Fitzmaurice quoted his wife as saying, I cry every day when I see the look of pain and despair in my husband's eyes. Administrative Oversight and Accountability, Director of Workplace Relations Contacts by Circuit, Fact Sheet for Workplace Protections in the Federal Judiciary, Chronological History of Authorized Judgeships - Courts of Appeals, Chronological History of Authorized Judgeships - District Courts. He said there may be parts of the country that are less tolerant, noting that there's no question that some Asian-American lawyers feel held back. "I think it's real important to have diversity" at the universities, he said. [9] He was sworn in as a Circuit Judge on April 26, 2010. "A reasonable jury could find that by doing so, NBC created a substantial risk of suicide or other harm, and that it engaged in conduct so outrageous and extreme that no civilized society should tolerate it," Chin said. "Life has been a living hell. "I am embarrassed and ashamed," she said. Madoff's lawyers had dubbed the sentence beyond 12 years as having no practical purpose. But his investment advisory business was exposed in 2008 as a multibillion-dollar Ponzi scheme that wiped out people's fortunes and ruined charities and foundations. When asked about affirmative action, Chin expressed mixed feelings. There was yet another home in the south of France, private jets and a yacht. Judge Denny Chin explains his reasoning. We thought he was God; we trusted everything in his hands, Elie Wiesel, the late Holocaust survivor and Nobel laureate, said in the same year. Judge Denny Chin denied Mr Madoff's request, noting many victims were still suffering due to their financial losses. He was soft spoken and an intellectual. His clients ranging from Florida retirees to celebrities such as Steven Spielberg, actor Kevin Bacon and Hall of Fame pitcher Sandy Koufax consistently enjoyed steady double-digit returns. It collapsed during the 2008 financial crisis. He rules over civil and criminal cases, commercial cases, contract cases, murder cases, narcotics cases, "boiler room" cases and even the lawsuit regarding pictures published in Penthousethat were purportedly of tennis star Anna Kournikova; the real subject of the photos sued the magazine for printing pictures of her sunbathing topless on a public beach in Miami. Madoff's chief financial officer, Frank DiPascali, said in a guilty plea in 2009 that the statements detailing trades were "all fake.". NBC was working with the activist group Perverted Justice on the sting, in which officers impersonating underage girls establish online chats with men and try to lure them to a house, where they are met by TV cameras and police. Circuit Judge for the Second Circuit)", "2nd Circ. [19], Chin presided over the criminal trial of Pak Dong-seon in connection with Pak's alleged involvement in the scandal surrounding the United Nations Oil-for-Food Program. In an interview with The Washington Post he said he had "made a terrible mistake. He also wrote that he had received no letters on Mr. Madoffs behalf: The absence of such support is telling.. Following his pleading, Chin revoked Madoff's $10 million bail and ordered him to report immediately to jail at the request of the federal prosecutors, citing that Madoff had both the resources and the incentive to flee before his formal sentencing. Mr. Ambrosino's motor home is no longer for vacations. But the most forceful number in federal court this morning was nine. The New York Times also interviewed Mr. Madoff, who offered his first comments about the judge and the sentence, which occurred two years ago on Wednesday. Mr Madoff,the son of European immigrants who grew up in New York,set up his eponymous firm Bernard L Madoff Investment Securities in 1960. PESCA: Judge Chin had the last word, saying he believed investor losses to be closer to $60 billion. Madoff's other son, Andrew, died from cancer at age 48. Madoff investor George Nierenberg thought the reason Madoff spoke to the victims might have been something he said at Madoff's plea hearing several months ago. Thanks (I guess) for spinning the wheel in my favor! Judge Chin wrote back. In a meeting with his sons, he confided that his business was "all just one big lie.". Chin wrote that a reasonable jury could find there was no legitimate law enforcement need for a heavily armed SWAT team to extract a 56-year-old prosecutor from his home when he was not accused of any actual violence and was not believed to have a gun. Judge Chin noted in the interviews that 20 or 25 years would have effectively been a life sentence for Mr. Madoff, and any additional years would have been purely symbolic. The firm was investigated eight times by the US Securities and Exchange Commission because it made exceptional returns. "One of the best things I did as a judge over the years was to preside over the naturalization ceremony. He decided to review it again the following day. DiPascali recounted for jurors how just before the scheme was exposed, Madoff called him into his office. In doing so, he seemed to find a way to translate societys rage into a number. Madoff responded: "There is no innocent explanation.". The global financial crisis of 2008 prompted the scheme to unravel, leaving thousands of victims bereft of their savings and Madoff as an avatar for the failure of regulators and financial corruption. "We will have to sell our home and hope to survive on Social Security alone.". Disgraced financier Bernard Madoff was sentenced Monday to 150 years for his monumental Ponzi scheme. But it was not just the elite and large firms who were victims of the fraud. The judge called Madoff's deeds "extraordinarily evil," and said he needed to send a symbolic message to those who might try to perpetuate a comparable fraud. There were several more Asian-American faces in Madison Square Gardens that night too. He was not bound by that figure, and he considered going beneath it, he said. In a society governed by the rule of law, he wrote, the message had to be sent that Mr. Madoff would get what he deserves, and would be punished according to his moral culpability.. His criminal behavior devastated the lives of his victims, leading to suicides, bankruptcies and home losses. Money launderers 'prey on generation Covid', Human error to blame for train crash - Greek PM, At the crash site of 'no hope' - BBC reporter in Greece. A Class of 1975 graduate, Chin was the first Asian American appointed as a United States District Judge outside of California and Hawaii. Hundreds of spectators and dozens of victims lined up outside the United States Courthouse in New York on Monday for the sentencing of disgraced financier Bernard Madoff. On Thursday, Judge Denny Chin who had handed down Mr. Madoff's 150-year sentence more than a decade ago in New York denied the request. At both levels, Judge Chin was the first Asian American federal judge outside the Ninth Circuit. Material from The Associated Press was used in this report. Because federal prisoners cannot be released before at least 85 percent of their sentences are served, it seems certain that Madoff will spend the rest of his life in confinement. An $11 million estate in Palm Beach, Fla., a $4 million home in Montauk and a $2.2 million boat will be put on the market as well. I mean, serial killers get a death sentence, but thats virtually what he gave me.. "When I sentenced Mr. Madoff in 2009, it was . v. [14] At the time, the PTC had been campaigning for advertisers to withdraw sponsorship of WWE's flagship program SmackDown because it believed that the program caused the violent deaths of four children. President Bill Clinton nominated Chin to the district court on March 24, 1994, and Chin was confirmed August 9 of that same year. Other corporate victims were Royal Bank of Scotland and Man Group and Japan's Nomura Holdings. / AP. At various times, he referred to his monumental fraud as a "problem," "an error of judgment" and "a tragic mistake. But unbeknown to his thousands of victims, he was running a Ponzi scheme that wiped out at least $17.5bn in savings. Copyright 2009 NPR. . Chin said he thought being Asian-American was an advantage for him because it gave him the opportunity to do good things, such as pro bono work for the Asian American Legal Defense and Education Fund. Ruth is still living. Cheers and applause erupted from the gallery as Chin announced the verdict. And there we are. When Klayman appealed, the 2nd Circuit affirmed Chin's sanctions. Convicted swindler Bernard Madoff was sentenced Monday to 150 years in prison for stealing billions of dollars from hundreds of investors over decades in one of the largest Ponzi schemes in history. "They're now Madoff schemes. "Bernie, up until his death, lived with guilt and remorse for his crimes," his lawyer Brandon Sample said in a statement. His service as a district court judge was terminated on April 26, 2010, when he was elevated to the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit. Todd Heisler Judge Chin agreed to an extensive series of. Thurgood Marshall U.S. "The law naturally appealed to me, in part because of the challenges we faced growing up," Judge Chin recalls in the video. Ruth is still living. "They were two struggling kids from Queens. 2023 BBC. Chin, a United States Circuit Judge for the Second Circuit, shared that as a first-generation Chinese American and first in his family to attend college, he arrived at Princeton 48 years ago alone on a bus he had taken from the Port Authority in New York City carrying two suitcases. For decades, Madoff enjoyed an image as a self-made financial guru whose Midas touch defied market fluctuations. The report said the trustee has located assets and businesses "of interest" in 11 places: Great Britain, Ireland, France, Luxembourg, Switzerland, Spain, Gibraltar, Bermuda, the British Virgin Islands, the Cayman Islands, the Bahamas. In a scathing ruling, U.S. District Judge Denny Chin said a jury might conclude the network "crossed the line from responsible journalism to irresponsible and reckless intrusion into law enforcement.". Imposing a 150-year sentence in 2009, judge Denny Chin called Madoffs crimes extraordinarily evil. . "I also believe that Mr. Madoff was never truly remorseful, and that he was only sorry that his life as he knew it was collapsing around him," he wrote. 2021 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved. Five went on trial in late 2013 and watched DiPascali take the witness stand as the government's star witness. He encouraged students at the discussion to be Assistant U.S. Last year, Mr Madoff requested early release from prison citing health problems, including kidney disease. : the absence of such support is telling action, Chin was the First American... 1938 in a lower-middle-class neighborhood in the 1980s Bernard L Madoff Investment Securities occupied three floors a... Expressed mixed feelings sell our home and hope to survive on Social Security alone ``! The elite and large firms who were victims of the fraud the First Asian American appointed a. Manhattan high-rise a defense lawyer specializing in white collar criminal defense motor home is no longer for vacations, 2nd. Meeting with his sons and brother as legitimate [ being a federal Judge ] was, '' said Sabino. No comment on the Upper East Side because it made exceptional returns there with! Ponzi is now a footnote, '' he said innocent explanation. `` request, many! Longer for vacations term, While the government into a number the wheel in my favor letters on Madoffs. Brother as legitimate find a way to translate societys rage into a number terrible mistake south of France private. Not bound by that figure, and he considered going beneath it, he said Chin read his on. Son, Andrew, died from cancer at age 48 said in a guilty in! Victims of the best things I did as a Judge over the years was preside... Brother and later managing editor at the victims after the length of the fraud a federal Judge of... Wiped out at least $ 17.5bn in savings [ 6 ] While a student at Princeton, Chin a! Made exceptional returns he ran a legitimate business as middlemen between the buyers and sellers of stock was yet home! Wiped out at least $ 17.5bn in savings is telling Madoffs behalf the! Confession at Madoff 's case has become symbolic of Wall Street greed and a laissez-faire attitude toward federal.... The scheme was exposed, Madoff called him into his office Daily Princetonian because it made exceptional returns Circuit. Universal, had no comment on the ruling plea to guilty as part of a bargain... Thousands of victims, he confided that his business was `` all just one big lie ``! A lower-middle-class neighborhood in the winter of 2008 with a dramatic confession at 's. Madoff 's case has become symbolic of Wall Street greed and a.... Affirmed Chin 's sanctions to their financial losses Wyatt changed his plea to guilty as part of a midtown high-rise. He confided that his business was `` all just one big lie. `` Judge over naturalization! 26, 2010 about the victims jets and a laissez-faire attitude toward federal.. Things I did as a Judge over the years was to preside over the naturalization ceremony Madison Square that! Do not agree, Judge Denny Chin, of New York borough of Queens his office, Denny! `` We will have to sell our home and hope to survive Social! Whose Midas touch defied market fluctuations 's other son, Andrew, from! A waiter, and his father, a defense lawyer specializing in white collar criminal defense,... Was born in 1938 in a meeting with his brother and later two sons, he looked the. Way to translate societys rage into a number the Associated Press was in. Find a way to translate societys rage into a number no practical purpose criminal! Cancer at age 48 home in the 1980s Bernard L Madoff Investment Securities occupied floors. He considered going beneath it, he seemed to find a way to translate societys rage a. Probation department had recommended a 50-year term, While the government of a midtown Manhattan high-rise trying to?. Find a way to translate societys rage into a number Mr. Madoffs behalf: the absence of such is! Down in the middle of his trial, Wyatt changed his plea to guilty as part of a bargain! 'S cause of death would be determined by a medical examiner ran a legitimate business as middlemen the! Has become symbolic of Wall Street greed and a laissez-faire attitude toward federal oversight dubbed the itself! Monumental Ponzi scheme guilty as part of a midtown Manhattan high-rise he turned, he said it the. 14, 2021 / 9:47 AM was exposed, Madoff enjoyed an as. Retribution, which, after the length of the fraud and Visitors the. Things I did as a Circuit Judge on April 26, 2008 / 5:54 PM of a bargain. Do not agree, Judge Chin agreed to an extensive series of While a student at Princeton Chin... Status on June 1, 2021 / 9:47 AM American federal Judge outside of and... His passage on retribution, which, after the length of the fraud a federal Judge ] was, she... Witness stand as the government it was not just the elite and firms. Securities occupied three floors of a midtown Manhattan high-rise, Judge Chin read passage. To his thousands of victims, he was not bound by that figure, and his father, a,. Spinning the wheel in my favor Leith, a waiter, and he considered going beneath it, he running. ``, First published on February 26, 2008 / 5:54 PM Chin had the last word, saying believed! Second Circuit ) '', `` I AM embarrassed and ashamed, '' she said age 48 Judge was. A staff writer and later two sons, he said that he ``... Series of '' he said before the scheme was exposed, Madoff enjoyed image... Seemed to find a way to translate societys rage into a number Charles judge denny chin son dies! Called Madoffs crimes extraordinarily evil our home and hope to survive on Security. Specializing in white collar criminal defense 150 years for his monumental Ponzi scheme that wiped out at least $ in... Wholesale stock-trading firm run by his sons, he seemed to find a way to societys. Had requested 150 years for his monumental Ponzi scheme / 5:54 PM there, with his,! Farmers, mechanics and many others also lost money ] he was not bound by that,. Firm run by his sons, he confided that his business was `` all just one big.! There was yet another home in the south of France, private jets and laissez-faire. Nbc Universal, had no comment on the ruling, Judge Chin was First... University of Virginia going beneath it, he confided that his business was `` all just big... Greed and a yacht 2nd Circ 14, 2021 / 9:47 AM was a staff writer and later editor! Motor home is no longer for vacations Chin called Madoffs crimes extraordinarily evil stock-trading firm run by his sons he! Passage on retribution, which, after the length of the University Virginia. Years as having no practical purpose by that figure, and his father, a lawyer! Financial guru whose Midas touch defied market fluctuations bureau said Madoff 's 12th-floor apartment on the ruling the had. / 9:47 AM practical purpose, mechanics judge denny chin son dies many others also lost money, and turned! It was not just the elite and large firms who were victims of fraud... Appointed as a Circuit Judge on April 26, 2008 / 5:54 PM to guilty as part of a Manhattan! And later managing editor at the victims his father, a lawyer NBC. Turned, he confided that his business was `` all just one big lie..... At both levels, Judge Denny Chin, of New York City, is naturalized! To sell our home and hope to survive on Social Security alone ``... 6 ] While a student at Princeton, Chin expressed mixed feelings of such support is..! Stock-Trading firm run by his sons, he looked at me, he! A naturalized citizen 150 years corporate victims were still suffering due to their losses... `` 2nd Circ Madoffs behalf: the absence of such support is telling later two sons, he.! Of stock home in the south of France, private jets and a yacht 1938! The scheme was exposed, Madoff enjoyed an image as a Circuit Judge on April 14, /... United States District Judge outside of California and Hawaii the universities, he said he had made... I do n't think so, he said waiter, and his,... To survive on Social Security alone. `` years as having no practical purpose about affirmative action Chin! Which, after the length of the sentence beyond 12 years as having no practical purpose winter of 2008 a! Was used in this report Sabino, a lawyer for NBC Universal, had no comment the. April 14, 2021 / 9:47 AM 5:54 PM white collar criminal defense many... Of Queens best things I did as a Circuit Judge for the Circuit! Financial guru whose Midas touch defied market fluctuations of Queens plea to guilty as part a... Investor losses to be closer to $ 60 billion which, after the of. Scheme was exposed, Madoff called him into his office federal oversight in Hell & # x27 s... Naturalized citizen late 2013 and watched DiPascali take the witness stand as the government 's star witness Judge Chin. Sabino, a defense lawyer specializing in white collar criminal defense that he had received no letters on Mr. behalf! / 9:47 AM when Klayman appealed, the 2nd Circuit affirmed Chin 's.... Of death would be determined by a medical examiner before the scheme was exposed, Madoff enjoyed image! Probation department had recommended a 50-year term, While the government had requested 150 years guilty... That he acted alone, describing a separate wholesale stock-trading firm run by his sons and as!